A collection of Facts, Opinions and Comments from survivors of Herbert W. Armstrong, Garner Ted Armstrong,  The Worldwide Church of God and it's Daughters.
Updated 08/07/07 11:57 AM PDT

The painful truth about Herbert W. Armstrong, Garner Ted Arrmstrong and the Worldwide Church of God

Articles Pertaining To Herbert W. Armstrong, Garner Ted Armstrong and The Worldwide Church of God

PT Home Page
Complete Articles Index
Featured Articles
2006 Articles
2005 Articles
2004 Articles
Read the Ambassador Report
Download the Ambassador Report  (Right-click and choose "Save Target") 12.2 megabytes

Email Index
Email The PT

Primary PT Sub-Pages
Herbert W. Armstrong and the Worldwide Church of God Exposed
What About the Bible?
The Age of Reason
Acts of God  
Alcoholism and the Worldwide Church of God   
Suicide and the Worldwide Church of God
Recommended Books
411, Information Please  
Death Notices For The Worldwide Church of God  
Prophecy Index
You might have grown up in the Worldwide Church of God if . . .
Garner Ted Armstrong and Geraldo Rivera Video Download
Stanley Rader on "Sixty Minutes" with Mike Wallace Audio download
The Graveyard Church of God
Google Adwords for Herbert W. Armstrong



Email To The Editor
(Page 97)



 After reading some not all; of your website I can see how bitter you are toward WCG and Mr. Armstrong. But maybe youíre asking too much of a man whoís been dead for 20 years? You should read his autobiography as well as everything else before passing judgment so you can make a truly enlightened judgment. See I donít care if you donít believe in God or His word Iím not the one you have to answer too. Iím not going to quote anything from the bible because youíre not going to read it. However I think you should tell the complete truth not just your viewpoint. The WCG did do a lot of things and Mr. Armstrong was by no means perfect however no human being is. We all sin only Christ was perfect and He did give us the ability to think freely. All your website does is stir up strife and hate. The problem in the church today is
that people arenít going to do whatís right either they donít know how or they donít want to. I feel sorry for all of those who were hurt by the church and the ministry God did not approve of those behaviors. Had Mr. Armstrong known he wouldíve put a stop to it. As far as the incest claims and the supposed drinking his own son Garner Ted denied ever accusing his father of incest saying that everything you need to know about my father is in his autobiography. Have you personally ever talked to any of the people who supposedly were involved? If you havenít all youíre doing is going by what you have heard or read. I do not agree with everything Mr. Armstrong said but I donít have too. The Church that Christ started is still in existence today albeit scattered and splintered over the entire world. Itís also fine if you wish to judge the church as a whole claiming that we are a cult. Again itís just your opinion. As for proofs that God
doesnít exist youíre free to believe whatever you want so why judge others for their beliefs? If you want to believe that you came from a rock thatís fine a lot of people believe that. I prefer to believe that I came from something smarter and greater then I am. If you consider this hate mail so what Iím not ashamed of anything I wrote. And you can insult me and belittle me all you want because I donít answer to you for my actions. Iím not going to waste my time
threatening you or insulting you. Those kinds of actions are foolish nonsense. And you can keep your website but you really should get all your facts straight before putting them out where everyone can see them. After looking up all of the so called painful truths that you looked at there are some serious questions that you should ask. Have you personally ever talked to any of the people who supposedly were involved? All I could find on The Ambassador Report
always seems to link to your website. That makes me believe that this publication never existed until later years. And David Robinsonís book doesnít prove anything. As I said earlier Garner Ted denied saying anything to his father about the alleged incest. WCG did make a lot of mistakes and did screw up peoples lives but to say that it was brainwashing us and making us believe in something that wasnít real that only shows 2 things. 1 That people are searching for something beyond this miserable human life or 2 We are so weak that we will follow only what people tell us and not look at things for ourselves. Mr. Armstrong did a lot of good things and to belittle him and make him out to be basically Satan himself all youíre doing is showing your ignorance and willingness to not think for yourself and to attempt to tear down someone
who while he was one of the weak and base things God was able to show us what could be done through man.

Dave Edwards dmedward@houston.rr.com

Whew!  Did you ever hear of paragraphs or punctuation?  Seems like everyone who writes here to defend Herbert is illiterate, or nearly so.  To be fair, you're better than most, but you really should take a class on how to write a dissident letter.

For a detailed response to your diatribe, go here.


Thank you, Retired Prof, for your articles submitted to The Painful Truth. Your approach to unbelief is refreshing. I, personally, am much happier and contented since timidly emerging from the "atheist closet" about ten-plus years ago than I ever was when I strove to believe.  

I spent most of my almost 70 years of life in a long, frustrating attempt to discover what God wanted from me, how to best please him, whether he really cared about human beings, and why the Bible, if it is truly the inerrant Word of a perfect God, is so confusing and generates so many diverse doctrines. This far-too-long attempt was, however, a decidedly well earned educational experience both in the Radio/Worldwide Church of God and later in orthodoxy. Obviously, it was very difficult for me to lay aside my cloak of Christianity. It was my security blanket.  

Now I am convinced that there is no god at all and that the Bible is primarily a control device authored by mere humans. As I have said in my second book in process, "Had I been less observant, less studious, less inquisitive, and even less sincere about discovering religious 'truth,' I would most probably still be a Christian."  

Again, thank you for your insight and allowing others to partake of it. 

Betty Brogaard


Reply to Dave Edwards


Dave I guess my experience was all in my head.  Boy they got you real good. 

I spent 17-plus years in the cult and I didn't join of my own free will either.   In the article I wrote, I explain that I do not feel ill-will to my parents.  I was brought in as a six year old child; I basically knew nothing else until I saw for myself the whole thing was a sham. 

I think that you may be a minister under an alias.  In today's world you can have multiple e-mail accounts, I should know I have THREE for myself ( all legit ).  I didn't know this site existed until about a year ago so this is not an endorsement for the site.  I studied many many things while in as well as after I left.  I have come to realize that TO ME ALL RELIGION IS A SHAM -- this includes the Bible.  

But since I was a part of the W.C.G. that is my life.  When you call ME a liar I take it personally.  Once you come to your senses (which I doubt uou will), you will see the extreme measures they used to cover their asses.  I find that most stories are similar in nature, but people like you REFUSE to see that.   We did not all get together and decide to speak out and spread lies like Ol' Herb did in his AUTOBIOGRAPHY.   We have come here individually to tell of our experiences to help those that are unsure of what happened and help those that are still in finally break free .   If this God did pick individuals as HIS apostles, why are they so unlike the "JESUS" character in the bible !!!!!!!?????? 

Jim Osia



Thanks for all the great resources youíve been providing.  Itís been a tremendous help in putting my Armstrongist past into perspective.

Right now Iím looking for a transcript of the divorce proceedings between HWA and his second wife Ramona.  I realize that there are quotes in the Ambassador Report, but being the nit picking type I am, Iíd like to see everything in context.

Do you happen to have that on this site, or know any other way of getting hold of it?

Thanks again and best wishes


Thanks for writing, Mickey.  I've never seen those transcripts either, and I don't know if anyone still has them.  I imagine they would still be on file at the courthouse where the proceedings took place, but I don't know if the public could get copies; even if you could, I suspect they wouldn't be cheap.  The raw transcript would have to be transcribed and, as of 1980, that cost about a dollar a page, so it would be much higher now. 

If anyone out there has access to existing copies and is willing to share them, please contact us.



Thanks to "Michael" for proving once again that there is life after WCG, any of its offshoots, and, indeed, everything else that puts us into a slumbering escape mode. Awakening from my own religious sleepwalking was a "resurrection" for me, a truly wonderful enablement!

One of the dictionary definitions of "resurrection" is "a revival after disuse, inactivity, or decay." By disengaging from the WCG and eventually stepping away from all organized religion, I revived, put my brain into reactivated use, and cut away the decay. Thanks, Michael, for telling us about your freeing experiences. 

Betty Brogaard



I ran across your site...I was reading your disclaimer, and you may or may not choose to post this message.

I grew up in the WCG... and went to Ambassador University... and got out in 1995... I fully agree... Herbert Armstrong was a false profit, and we were in a cult! Most of my childhood was spent trying to be good enough to make it into the kingdom of God, so that I could one day teach all of my "nonWCG" friends at school the truth about the Holy Days and the Sabbath and Clean and Unclean meats.

After attending A.U. for 2 years, I left when it all came down (and thank God that it did)... I moved to Vail CO, and lived a "Godless" life for about 8 years, filled with self gratification and "livin' life to the fullest", all for me.

In 2003, after hitting rock bottom... I became a follower of Jesus, and asked him to be my savior... The real Jesus... not the false Jesus that we learned about in WCG, not Armstrong's version of Jesus.

My life is completely different, and Jesus has changed me...I've been working as a youth minister on a native american reservation with youth ages 12 and up... most of which have been sexually abused, or suffer from addictions... I believe that the Bible is innerant and that there is a God, and that God came to earth as Jesus... and by repenting and putting your faith in Jesus, he gives us the free gift of eternal life in heaven.(no strings attached) I realize that this is my belief, and we have free will, and you have free will to believe what you want to believe.

The last four years of my life have far exceded, (especially in the "peace" department) the previous years both in the cult, and in living a life choosing "no God" for 8 years... Herbert Armstrong mislead and deceived MANY people... and he deceived us about the true Jesus and true God.

Blessings... you may post my name, if you chose to post this writing.

tom burnett


Tom,  I'm glad you found a solution that works for you.  Unlike some "exit and support" websites, we here at the Painful Truth believe, above all else, in freedom of choice, especially where religion is concerned.  Some people are comfortable with religion, some are not; some find the Bible convincing, others do not.  You are clearly aware that I don't share your beliefs, but you seem to have things together in your life (perhaps for the first time), so why should I try to ruin a winning formula?  I am especially impressed that you are working with underprivileged children; I applaud that.  The only word of caution that I would offer is that, when it comes to religion, I hope you will extend to them the same freedom of choice that you enjoy, even if you disapprove of what that choice might be.

Thanks for writing.



Here are a few more names that should be added to your list.

Bob League, one of the worst, his meanness too long to mention. He is in with Meridith.  Fred Coulter, no longer in WW, but has his own church, just like the rest.

Ron Weinland, a terror if ever there was one. Has his own church.

Ed Smith, he was a regional director for a time, he resigned a long time ago, but he stayed with WW, then he went into United, and is a big influence there still.

Al Dennis, now deceased, but a real mean dude if ever there was one. He started his own church after leaving WW, and also was in United.

John Elliott, he caused division among the brethren and disfellowshipped some sincere and honest people who just didn't agree with him.

With the exception of Fred Coulter, all these men were in Cincinnati, and I knew them very well.

I was with Fred Coulter in his group for a time, I even worked for him before and know him to be a liar.

All of these were ungodly and some were just plain despicable.

You can use my name.

Clyde E Brown



Dear friend,

If you truly wish to help those who have been victimized by Herbert Armstrong's falsehoods you will post on your website for everyone to send the information they read to these e-mail addresses

and any others who support armstrongs work and you also take a leap of faith and do this yourself.For it is said






We are in the last hour my friend talk is cheap if you will not stand up for yourselves and others for if you choose not to do something when you had the chance to, you will be held accountable on judgment day. Please have faith and trust in God and the Son of Man for they do love you and have passed judgment for you.


Please friend have faith

gr jones [tuesdaythursday@yahoo.com]

Watch out for the Kool-Aid, Gr. Jones!



I will tell you a mystery my friend the elect can not be deceived, for they are the body of Christ and are not in any church organization ordained by men

And it is said It is these that have not defiled themselves with women for they are chaste




Is that you again, Gr. Jones?  We'll get right on it.  Where do we send the money?



Heb 8:8The days will come says the Lord when I will establish a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah not like the covenant that I made with their fathers on the day when I took them by the hand to lead them out of Egypt for they did not continue in my covenant so I paid them no heed says The Lord 

This is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days says The Lord :

I will put my laws into their minds and write them on their hearts and I will their God and they shall be my people and they SHALL NOT TEACH EVERYONE HIS FELLOW OR EVERYONE HIS BROTHER SAYING KNOW THE LORD FOR ALL SHALL KNOW ME from the least of them to the greatest for I will be merciful toward their iniquities and I will remember their sins no more. you people just don't get it do you

come out of her my people

Okay, jerkoff, the party's over.  Your first letter was a bit amusing, the second was entertaining, but now you're becoming a bore.  First you talked about people being victimized by Herbert Armstrong; if you dislike him so much, how come you sound exactly like him?  Your letters are absolutely insane; they make no sense at all.  "you people just don't get it do you"  Yes, I get it just fine.  You've never heard of punctuation, you're drinking Kool-Aid, you're a Keeper Of Odd Knowledge (KOOK), and you're a freak. 

By using a different phony email address each time, I assume you're worried about being tracked down?  No doubt the government is looking for you, eh?  You dive into the bushes each time a black helicopter passes over?  Well I got news for you: THEY ALREADY KNOW WHERE YOU ARE!  Wanna know something else?  THEY DON'T CARE!  They've got much more important fish to fry.  And, yeah, from the ground ALL HELICOPTERS LOOK BLACK!  That's because they're too far away to make out their true colors.

We won't be posting any more of your sewage.  If you want attention, write your message on a piece of cardboard and stand by the freeway.  Someone might give you some money...if they don't run over you first.



When he entered into the Temple, the chief priests and elders asked Jesus, "By what authority doest thou these things? and who gave thee this authority?"

Jesus answered by asking them a question about authority and then went on to give a parable about two sons. The point Jesus made was that the one who has the authority is the one who does the job.

For over twenty years, the various Churches of God haven't seemed to agree on anything, whether it be the Calendar, whether or not to eat out on the Sabbath in restaurants, whether the foot washing comes first at Passover and so on. There is however, one topic upon which all leaders of the Churches of God should be able to agree and that is on the topic of Alcoholism.

Herein are links to articles on Alcoholism for the edification of all the Churches of God, the ministers, leaders and membership. The authority upon which the articles are based is that the methods work. No other authority is needed.

The articles are based upon what Mr. Dennis Luker called back in 1982, "The Luker Challenge", which goes like this: [concerning alcohol] "If you say you can do without it, then prove it!" With that challenge Mr. Luker lay down the gauntlet based on "Rational Recovery" - that is to say, instant permanent total abstinence from alcohol. It works and has worked for millions of people. It may even be that many did not know that they were using rational recovery, but they were using it and it worked for them.

As Christians, all of us should be quite aware that it is not acceptable to be a practicing alcoholic. Alcoholism needs to be managed by those who are afflicted by it.

I spoke briefly with Mr. Luker after Sabbath Services at the end of December

2006 and promised that I would write an article on the topic.

All of you may use this material without restriction, except that, it must be used in its entirety with nothing deleted, although it is acceptable to "flesh out" the article.

I will also be passing this information on to Jack and Lois Trimpey at Rational.org. We have exchanged information in the past.

The topic of alcoholism has profound implications for the membership of all the churches of God whether or not they are alcoholics. Even if a person is not an alcoholic in the Churches of God, they know an alcoholic whether or not they are aware of it. It is time that this particular problem is resolved everywhere within the Churches of God. It should be the one thing all the Churches can agree on.

It would be nice to resolve one problem before the end of the period of testing over the next twenty years.



Douglas Becker



To Douglas Becker-

I respond to your open letter to Christians. Happily, I am not one now but I learned alot
about the stresses of religion while wasting 25 years of my life in the WCG.

I found it interesting years ago to attend the Refresher Courses in Pasadena. I foolishly
anticipated learning who the Beast was, the truth of 666, or at least the name of one of
the two witnesses. Boy! Was I wrong!

Most of the lectures from the inadequately-educated personnel consisted of instructing
church pastors in handling the problems of the weak humans under their care. There
was little discussion of the Bible as that was under the heavy hand of Herb and not open
to debate.

I recall in particular the alcohol discussion presented by Herman L. Haywire. He told us
that most of the drinking problems in the church were manifested by members who
formerly had no problems. Some never touched the stuff. That was some news.

After I left in disgust fifteen years ago I spent quite some time in recovery from my church
experience. I also reflected on the earlier statement concerning problems of alcoholism in
the church. I realized that the need to drink likely came about as a result of trying to cope
with the mad world of COGism. To attempt to make sense out of insanity is a sure recipe
for seeking solace in the bottle.

It was once said that insanity is to keep practicing the same actions while expecting
different results. Your letter is testimony to that. You counsel to just say no to alcohol.
What about really biting the bullet and dumping the source of the stress--religion.
Unfortunately, the walkaways are few in number but those that have exited greatly reduced
the amount of personal stress in life. I know for sure.

Jim Baldwin



I wrote you back on 2/23/07, on page 96 of the e-mail index.

Just want to thank you for the website. I can only speak for myself, but I think that for those of us who have "come out," and who have lucked upon the Painful Truth, it is nice to come here once in a while and see how things are going, and that others come to the site and find helpful links, and a common experience.

I'd like to recommend a new book if that's alright. It's the best thing I've read, and I absolutely love the author. It's called God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything by Christopher Hitchens. If I could meet this guy, I'd shake his hand and buy him his drink of choice.

Take care everyone.

To thine own self be true.




Hello Guys...(sorry, but obviously I got AOL)...

Ugh, Ugh, Ugh....I came across this guy on some forum thread...Thought all rabid Herbie/WCG lovers were hopefully dead by now...But shoot, guess there's still some around...Maybe you've come across some of these nutcases...

Boy, when this guy's on a thread he's gotta' hog the whole thing....Constantly preaching...This delusional asshole writes...

..."In the Wonderful World Tomorrow, everybody will know Herbert W. Armstrong and the Church of God were actually PIONEERS of the way all will then live."...

Oh, Puke!!!.....

Here's his insane blog link...


take care and have fun...

Thanks, Lynn.  This guy's name keeps popping up here and there.  Apparently he's a real zealot.  Hopefully he isn't dangerous, but I wouldn't want to sleep in the same room with him.



Dear Webmaster of the Painful Truth, 

At http://www.hwarmstrong.com/renehan-hearsay.htm I found the following anecdote drawn allegedly from HWA's Autobiography: 

"Then Robinson reminded me of a bizarre story in Armstrong's autobiography where he had left his son Richard alone at a railway station to find his own way from Oregon to Los Angeles. In the book Armstrong praised himself for teaching leadership to the young boy. In reality, Loma had suspected that Armstrong was innappropriate with her daughter Dorothy. Armstrong was leaving on a long journey by train and was only taking Dorothy with him. Loma insisted that Richard go too. Thus, Armstrong abandoned his son at the train station and proceeded on with just Dorothy." 

Would you kindly send me the volume and chapter reference to the Autobiography where this incident is related because a search using various key words failed to locate this on my (searchable) PDF copy of HWA's Autobiography? 


Henk Jens

I wish I could help you out, Henk, but I tossed all my WCG publications more than 15 years ago.  I haven't spoken to Bruce Renehan since 1999 and no longer have any way to contact him.  What I can suggest is that, if any readers here still have copies of the HWA Autobiography, they might be able to find the passage in question and let us know.  If that happens, the Painful Truth will publish the information..

If you are using a pdf version of the Autobiography, chances are that it has been edited, or the search index doesn't contain what you are looking for.  I do remember that the Autobiography went through several editions, and the later ones were often much thinner than the original.  WCG quite often made attempts to tone down their hysteria as time went on and public scrutiny became more likely.  Many booklets (such as the U.S. and British Commonwealth in Prophecy) were severely edited and many others (e.g., 1975 In Prophecy) simply went out of print.


Painful Truth Editor:


Just accidentally swept across your site and you are still the clueless ass hole that you have always been.


Thank you for that insightful observation.  I am particularly pleased with your detailed, in-depth explanation as to WHY I am clueless.  If you have anything further to add, feel free to telephone me at BR-549.

P.T Editor

(P.S.  How does one "accidentally" sweep across our site?)

(P.P.S.  Just for your edification, "asshole" is one word, not two.)



Pain Truth
      At Feast time, When offering are taken
       Lev 23 is read.
       most hear
           .... ye shall make an offering.....

     But I read
           .....offering made by fire....
   Lets do a boolean word search on

            made AND fire     in OT

     I get 75 strikes
    Read carefully read each of those verses.

     noting the words;     Priest, Altar,fire, Burnt, sweet savour

     That's right!    an offering by fire is a sacrifice!
    Despite the claim that sacrifices were added later.

    Those collections were like Fund raising events

     J Garber     olecatnaper@yahoo.com

Okay, Jerry!  Thanks for clearing that up.



Just wanted to say how impressed I was over Bruce's letter about our future. He's a powerful writer and it serves as a reminder to all of us how our future is in our hands.

As a school teacher, I believe that Bruce hit it on the head when he said it was about caring. I think that is 99% of the issue. I see students without any hope at all of making it in their future. I know that I'm not the only educator out there trying to encourage these kiddos. Sometimes, it works when I tell the children that I believe in them....and I do believe in them, but many times, they just don't believe me. I've seen the kindness of strangers that say a positive comment like, "Wow! You are really good at that!" and the child believe them because they have heard it over and over again...even if it isn't from their parents.

I guess I would just like to add, if you see a child, any child, including your own, find something positive to say to them. You may be the ONLY positive influence that child hears. Try to stay clear from the appearance comments though...IE: You are very pretty, what a handsome man you are. Say things like, you are a great help, or you have a nice personality...Anyway, I think you get the point...

Bruce, you did an awesome job on your article. I really enjoyed reading it.

Warmest Regards,

~Angel =)

Thanks, Angel.  Great to hear from you.



You have an interesting and thorough website.  I'm not sure to what degree you are repudiating Christianity, or just the WCG.  I can relate as a person who was deeply depressed by the premillennial "immanent rapture" theology.  By God's grace I was introduced in 1993 to a book by David Chilton called "Paradise Restored".  Since then I have become a student of history and preterism and can see how the vast majority of the events referred to in Biblical prophecy took place in the first century at the time of the Jewish War and destruction of Jerusalem.  It is tragic how many Christians today are totally wrapped up with studying prophecy that was long ago fulfilled as if it will happen in their lifetime AT ANY MINUTE. It's no better than reading horoscopes.

I am interested in the history of the WCG.  Perhaps you can answer a question that isn't on your website for me:

You have posted Ernest Martin's resignation from the WCG over the question of whether Pentecost was on Sunday or Monday.  In that letter he mentions a paper that he wrote some years before on the subject, which fell into the "wrong hands" and became the tripwire that set off the explosion between him and Armstrong.

Do you have a copy of that paper?  I would be very interested in reading it.  If can get your hands on it, please post a link to it on your website.

In retrospect it is funny that Pentecost was almost 100% certainly on Saturday - something that Armstrong and crew would have rejoiced to have proved.  I've noticed that Martin and several others have made the same mistake by assuming the Crucifixion was on Friday, when the "Day of Preparation" referred to in Scripture is speaking of the day before the Feast of Firstfruits, which fell on Friday that year (31), making the crucifixion on Thursday.

God bless,
Ken Griffith

Thanks for writing, Ken.

To answer your first question, the primary purpose of this website is to expose the Armstrong empire for what it was, and continues to be under many other jurisdictions.  As for Christianity, many of our contributors are still believers, but the majority are not.  We try to expose the fallacies of religion in general as we see them, then let people decide for themselves.  Unlike those we oppose, we don't try to force-feed anyone.

As for Ernest Martin, I'm not aware of that particular paper or where it might be. I'm quite certain we don't have a copy, but if the article you read was part of Ambassador Report, it's quite likely that John Trechak had a copy.  Unfortunately he is no longer liv\ing.  My best guess would be to try the Associates for Scriptural Knowledge website, which I believe is maintained by Martin's son.  Good luck in your quest.

Pentecost?  Your theory makes as much sense as any other, but I really don't care.

John B


Hello, Mr. Griffith-

Your reference to Preterism will probably go right by many since it is one
of the more obscure of the weird doctrines the various branches of
Christianity have formulated.

I'm writing because Preterism was quite instrumental in my recovery after
25 years in Armstrongism. I was a walkaway on July 4, 1992. (You can read
an interview with me on the 2006 articles page.)

As I was preparing to leave the cult in the late winter of '92 I was in a college
library browsing the wonderful supply of periodicals on hand. As was usual, I
picked up the recent copy of Christianity Today. They had been commenting
on the changes within the WCG and I was looking for the latest news from their

After glancing through the articles I started to read the classified section.
There was a big, bold question: "What Happened in 70 A.D.?" by one Edward
Stevens. I'm sure you know the booklet.

Well, Sir, that booklet led to several months of study leading me away from
Armstrongism, premillennialism, biblicism, Christianity and theism.

It seems you are in the early stages of complete freedom, too.

I was at first drawn by the brief preterist booklet. Then I studied more about
the problems of the Bible and rejected the theory of Bible inspiration It
simply isn't true.

Preterism collapsed, also, not because premillennialism was found right but
because there isn't going to be a return. Jesus is a fiction.

The WCG was an aggressive premillennialist cult looking for the return of Christ.
That hope was to be realized "soon." Yeah, right.

As you know, the Preterists claim the return had already happened in 70 AD.

After some months of study I came to understand that the premillennialists
hold the kingdom to come as a reality awaited. In order to make any sense
out of the imminency statements of the NT they have to spirtualize those
promises of imminency.

Now the preterists make a similar flip. They believe in the statements of
imminency as given. Then they have to spirtitualize the kingdom promises
since it didn't happen in 70 AD.

Both groups cling to their particular conflicting interpretations in order to
hold out Christ of the Bible as not being the false prophet he was.

In addition to the Chilton book you ought to read these:

Robert G. Clouse, ed.--The Meaning of the Millennium: Four Views
Gary DeMar--Last Days Madness
A.J. Mattill, Jr.--Luke and the Last Things
(To be studied with a copy of the Weymouth NT, 3rd Edition, 1909.)

I wish you good days of happy research and critical thought.

Jim Baldwin



Give spam the boot. Take control with tough spam protection
in the all-new Yahoo! Mail Beta.


Email By Pages



If you have anything you would like to submit to this site,
or any comments, email me at:

Back to Painful Truth menu


The content of this site, including but not limited to the text and images herein and their arrangement, are copyright © 1997-2006 by The Painful Truth. All rights reserved.

Do not duplicate, copy or redistribute in any form without prior written consent.